April 5th, 2006

Advertisers Get Wise to Risks of MySpace and Web 2.0

by Scott Karp

I’ll resist the temptation to say I told you so about big brand advertisers not wanting to take the risk of appearing next to questionable content on MySpace, other Web 2.0 sites, and ad networks (although I did tell you). Articles on this phenomenon are appearing more frequently, the latest from the Wall Street Journal:

Most ad networks say they review the sites in their network regularly to check for inappropriate content. But David Herpers, chief marketing officer for Amerisave Mortgage Corp. says he bought an ad that appeared on MySpace from a network that promised to run them on “loans and money and finance” sites. Yet in the past month, Amerisave learned that its ad was adjacent to a photo of the male anatomy on a page on MySpace. “It’s really alarming….I had no idea that this could conceivably happen,” Mr. Herpers says.

Oh, the naivety all around. Here’s another priceless example:

Glitches have occurred for mundane reasons. The Christian Children’s Fund bought ads on the largest online ad network, Advertising.com, which is owned by AOL, and specified that the ads not appear near any provocative content. But Advertising.com says it mistakenly turned off its content filters for an unspecified period of time last month, and the Christian Children’s Fund ad ended up next to an article about a sexual position in the sex section of About.com, which is owned by New York Times Co. The Disney ads were also placed by Advertising.com on About.com’s sex section during that time.

The best part is that News Corp (finally looking out for it’s shareholders), is taking a giant step back from all the messiness of user-generated content and Web 2.0:

MySpace, which is owned by News Corp., says that the personal Web profiles by its more than 50 million members can be racy. But it’s building new sections of the site for movies and music. “You’ll see us roll out more and more traditional controlled content of the kind that advertisers expect,” says Ross Levinsohn, president of Fox Interactive Media, which oversees MySpace.

So it’s all about CONTROL — hmm, where have I heard that before?

Let me be clear — I’m NOT saying that advertisers should not or will not ultimately cede control (although when they do, they need to be careful with products that people hate). I’m saying that until they do, it’s going to be a huge barrier to Web 2.0 profits.

Comments (4 Responses so far)

  1. The real question is will myspace users find controlled content on myspace compelling. Sure, they’ll generate a lot of pageviews with that stuff, but how interesting will myspacers really find it? They need to hit a home run with those controlled areas, a base-hit isn’t going to cut it, given the expectations people have for moetizing myspace.

  2. â?? recommendations? — Chad Dickersonâ??s blog I’ve always found that when web projects get difficult enough that you’re tempted to whip out something like MS Project, it’s time to simplifyPublishing 2.0 Â? Advertisers Get Wise to Risks of MySpace and Web 2.0 I’m NOT saying that advertisers should not or will not ultimately cede control. I’m saying that until they do, it’s going to be a huge barrier to Web 2.0 profits. Read/WriteWeb: Google Base begins to roll out the verticals

  3. â?? recommendations? — Chad Dickersonâ??s blog I’ve always found that when web projects get difficult enough that you’re tempted to whip out something like MS Project, it’s time to simplifyPublishing 2.0 Â? Advertisers Get Wise to Risks of MySpace and Web 2.0 I’m NOT saying that advertisers should not or will not ultimately cede control. I’m saying that until they do, it’s going to be a huge barrier to Web 2.0 profits. Read/WriteWeb: Google Base begins to roll out the verticals

  4. […] Given that they are not depending on the good grace of advertisers, they don’t have the same concerns as MySpace does over how content appears to big brands. […]

  5. I’m with Ted on this one.

Subscribe without commenting

Add Your Comment

Subscribe

Receive a free daily email newsletter with new Publishing 2.0 posts


Publish2

Publish2 is a web-based newswire that makes it easy for journalists and newsrooms to gather, publish, and distribute links to the best news on the web. Like traditional newswires, the Publish2 newswire is a cooperative effort -- tapping into the collective editorial judgement of newsrooms and independent journalists, distributing links across the newswire and driving traffic to high quality journalism. Our mission is to help journalism survive and thrive on the Web by promoting the practice of link journalism.


Publish2 Posts

Media 2.0 Workgroup
Clicky Web Analytics
Close
E-mail It