May 19th, 2006

MySpace Hallucinations

by Scott Karp

So great is the hype surrounding MySpace that people are starting to hallucinate, seeing operating income where there are only registered users and page views. This is from a Motley Fool article on News Corp’s recent earnings release, which I cited in a previous post:

It bears noting that MySpace is only a small part of the News Corp. empire, yet the company’s television, movie, and other media properties aren’t doing too shabbily, either. The other sectors may not have the sex appeal of MySpace, but they are generating gobs of cash — more than $2 billion so far this year — and that inflow is no doubt funding numerous initiatives that aim to meld the content platforms together.

This is from a summary of the Motley Fool article that appeared in a Media Post email newsletter:

To be sure, MySpace is still a tiny part of News Corp, though it represents most of the company’s opportunity for growth: it’s already generated $2 billion in cash this financial year, about four times what News Corp paid for it nearly a year ago [bold is mine]; it also averaged 30 billion page views in April, placing it second among all Web sites, according to Nielsen/NetRatings.

Now here’s News Corp’s consolidated income statement:

News Corp Operating Income

And here’s the only mention of MySpace in News Corp’s earnings release:
“

This quarter also saw accelerated progress in our new media evolution. MySpace expanded to over 70 million registered users, solidifying its prominence as one of the fastest growing sites on the Internet.

Note to MediaPost: OOPS! It’s actually the OLD MEDIA businesses thatare kicking off all that cash, NOT MySpace. And all News Corp currently has to show for its MySpace bet is users and page views, NOT operating income.

I wouldn’t normal go out of my way to embarrass a group like MediaPost, because I like their stuff, but this is so representative of the hype in the market. The way people talk about MySpace you’d think that it’s ALREADY generating $2 billion in operating income.

But it’s NOT. And the truth is that they have NOT figured it how to do it yet — which doesn’t mean they won’t. If they do, more power to them.

In the meantime, let’s be careful not to drink too much of that spiked Kool-Aid, lest we start to party like it’s 1999 again and see profits where there are only “eyeballs.”

Comments (6 Responses so far)

  1. Nice view! I was looking for such numbers around the Net: nothing, nothing except articles on “expected revenues” or “potential growth”. One thing, at least, cost of hosting is about $6 M … Check here:
    http://biz.yahoo.com/bizj/060517/1289617.html?.v=1

  2. […] Scott Karp over at Publishing 2.0 is getting his panties in a twist over all that MySpace hype: MediaPost got that stats way out, he says. It’s not MySpace that is making the money for News Corp but the old media stuff - and no-one has quite figured out how to monetise a community and content sharing network of (as of this moment) 79,143,728 people. […]

  3. […] Scott Karp of Publishing 2.0 has a great piece on irrational exuberance over MySpace. […]

  4. […] Maybe people like Umair and Jeff operate on a different plane where they can see the dollars even though they don’t reference them explicitly. But if you read News Corp’s quarterly report, MySpace’s ostensible success at the edge is still not reportable in dollars and cents. […]

  5. […] Publishing 2.0 » MySpace Hallucinations"So great is the hype surrounding MySpace that people are starting to hallucinate, seeing operating income where there are only registered users and page views." […]

  6. […] Maybe people like Umair and Jeff operate on a different plane where they can see the dollars even though they don’t reference them explicitly. But if you read News Corp’s quarterly report, MySpace’s ostensible success at the edge is still not reportable in dollars and cents. […]

Subscribe without commenting

Add Your Comment

Subscribe

Receive a free daily email newsletter with new Publishing 2.0 posts


Publish2

Publish2 is an online news aggregation platform, designed to empower journalists to discover, organize, and rank the most important news -- to benefit their own reporting, their newsrooms, and all news consumers on the web. More about Publish2


Publish2 Posts


Media 2.0 Workgroup
Clicky Web Analytics
Close
E-mail It