April 12th, 2007

Do MySpace Users Care That It’s Not Really THEIR Space?

by

Last spring I wrote a post “Has The MySpace Downturn Begun?” Dan Mitchell at NYT picked it up in a piece “MySpace No Longer Their Space?” My post was purely speculative and, not surprisingly, completely wrong. But the fact remains that MySpace belongs to News Corp, not MySpace users, which is why News Corp can set the rules for ItsSpace, such as blocking third-party widgets like Photobucket.

MySpace blocked Photobucket because it was serving ads on MySpace without paying MySpace — the reaction in the blogosphere has focused on the implications to Web 2.0 business models — see Om Malik’s 5 lessons and Nick Carr’s sharecropping analogy.

The more interesting question to me — and the one that will have the greatest business consequences — is how do MySpace users feel about this? Clearly, most of them don’t know nor could care less about the spat over who controls the ad revenue. All they know is that their Photobucket videos suddenly went kaput.

Last year, I might have argued that this was a bad omen for MySpace. Now, I’m not so sure. After all, video hosting is fast becoming a commodity — MySpace users can turn to dozens of different service providers to replace Photobucket.

I bet most MySpace users are savvy enough to know it’s not really THEIR space — and I bet most of them don’t care.

Comments (6 Responses so far)

  1. Do MySpace Users Care That It’s Not Really THEIR Space? Thu Apr 12 11:24:42 UTC 2007 via Publishing 2.0

  2. Hi,

    I really do not think that My Space users care if it is actually there space or not!
    The users are there for two things…to advertise their internet projects(websites)
    or to try and gain some popularity by voicing their own opinions. Showing off in
    a negative way seems to be the most popular right now.l

    Thank you Kindly,
    VictoryWins

  3. WRONG — 75% of MySpacers have no clue what ad revenue is, let alone contemplate whether or not it’s truly theirs.

  4. [...] Check out Scott Karp’s similar observations: http://publishing2.com/2007/04/12/do-myspace-users-care-that-its-not-really-their-space/ [...]

  5. AnderSon,

    75% of MySpacers have no clue what ad revenue is, let alone contemplate whether or not it’s truly theirs.

    Clearly, most of them don’t know nor could care less about the spat over who controls the ad revenue.

    Isn’t that more or less what I said?

  6. [...] 1. New York Times becomes an aggregator The New York Times, paper of record and one of the… Do MySpace Users Care That ItÂ’s Not Really THEIR… Publishing 2.0 Apr 12, 2007 6:24:42 AM Last spring I wrote a post “Has The MySpace Downturn [...]

  7. [...] a hard time for not recognizing that they should have already cut a deal to compensate MySpace: Do MySpace Users Care That It’s Not Really THEIR Space? MySpace Kicks Back Ads on PhotoBucket: When is a Social Media Partner Really a [...]

Add Your Comment

Subscribe

Receive new posts by email