April 20th, 2007

Media’s Heavy Burden Of Responsibility

by Scott Karp

So much punditry on media, so many facile views, so little understanding of media’s heavy burden of responsibility. This is from an NPR interview with Dr. Joshua Sparrow a child psychiatrist and the head of outpatient psychiatry at Children’s Hospital in Boston, one of the top hospitals specializing in pediatric care, an assistant professor at Harvard Medical School, and Director of Special Initiatives at the Brazelton Touchpoints Center, i.e. he’s somebody who actually knows something about what’s at stake. Dr. Sparrow talked about the potential impact of unfettered distribution of “content” from the Virginia Tech shooter’s “multimedia manifesto”:

NPR: There’s the story itself, which was horrific enough, but then we’ve the impact of the video that was made by the shooter, and that has been repeating over and over again. Does that have a particular impact on children to see this young man in what almost looks like a movie pose.
Dr. Sparrow: I have a number of concerns about that. First of all, we have seen in previous school shootings and now with this one too the copycat phenomenon, and I don’t want to speculate about what was going on this young man’s mind, but one can perhaps speculate that he was hungry to be heard. In fact, dying to be heard, if he went to this trouble to video himself and send it off in the midst of the killings. We also know that this young man, like some of the others, was very fascinated by other mass murders. So by providing children and adolescents with all of this exposure, I think we run the risk of feeding that kind of curiosity in the very, very small number of children.

Comments (2 Responses so far)

  1. There was a backlash against NBC and their self-interested broadcast of the Cho tapes — but it centered around the hurt it added to the victim’s families. While that is certainly significant, there doesn’t seem to be an appreciation of the larger issue that media obsession with these murderers make the next incidence more likely.

  2. Is it the media obsession or access (to the media/to the weapons?)
    Believe me, the British media has just as deep an obsession with multiple murders - and with celebrity (infamy) But, so far, we haven’t had the copycat effect.
    Perhaps it’s the availability of weaponry. Knife crime is a growing issue in the UK. Knives are easy to acquire. One man with a knife can’t go on a spree. One man with a gun may be a different matter. Culture or availability?

Subscribe without commenting

Add Your Comment

Subscribe

Receive a free daily email newsletter with new Publishing 2.0 posts


Publish2

Publish2 is a web-based newswire that makes it easy for journalists and newsrooms to gather, publish, and distribute links to the best news on the web. Like traditional newswires, the Publish2 newswire is a cooperative effort -- tapping into the collective editorial judgement of newsrooms and independent journalists, distributing links across the newswire and driving traffic to high quality journalism. Our mission is to help journalism survive and thrive on the Web by promoting the practice of link journalism.


Publish2 Posts

Media 2.0 Workgroup
Clicky Web Analytics
Close
E-mail It